Monday, June 22, 2020

गुरु का साया

जीवन में उसने ही कुछ पाया जिसको मिला गुरु का साया
सुख तो सुख ही रहे उसके, दुःखों से भी उसने सुख ही पाया
 जिसको मिल जाए गुरु का साया

जीवन में जो आनंद बरसाए
मान-अपमान अंतर को छू ना पाए
अद्भुत विस्मय में कटता जीवन
प्रबल हो सामने आता वर्तमान क्षण
ॐ ॐ में लय हो जाता
अतुल्य तेज बल वो पाता
हो जाती अग्नि जैसी काया
जिसको मिल जाता गुरु का साया

देव ,यक्ष ,गन्धर्व ,किन्नर करे सेवा जिसकी
परम प्रेम छवि उसकी
भक्ति रस को जो समझाए
सत्य ज्योति से साक्षात्कार कराये
जो जला दे ह्रदय में ज्ञान की ज्वाला
खोल दे बुद्धि से इच्छाओं का ताला
छिन्न-भिन्न  हो जाती मोह-माया
जब मिल जाता गुरु का साया



Friday, March 29, 2019

Becoming a Freelancer as a Finance Professional

I have been toying with the idea of going freelance at some point. To this end, Toptal appears to be an excellent option. But can I succeed at it?

As a finance professional I have more than 6 years of experience working for PricewaterhouseCoopers, having done 2 years of audit and 4 years of financial due diligence work. Prior to that I have worked 6 years as a software engineer, developing online solutions using Java technology stack. Academically, I am a Chartered Accountant in England & Wales, hold an MBA (Strategy) from the University of Oxford and have an engineering degree from the Indian Institute of Technology (Industrial Design). 

My experience and academic background places me in the unique niche of somebody who has deep understanding and appreciation of both Finance and Technology. This reflects in my formidable financial modelling skills and a systematic approach to problem solving. I am also able to appreciate point of views of different workstreams and act as a project manager for multi-disciplinary projects. In the past 6 years I have worked on a wide variety of financial due diligence projects, including buy side assistance, vendor due diligence, working capital review, refinancing, deal specific bespoke financial analysis and long form reports for IPO. I have worked for both Private Equity and Corporate buyers across e-commerce, business services, energy, infrastructure, logistics and utilities. Deal sizes vary between £70m to £1bn. The projects typically involve working with C-suite executives, lawyers, investment bankers, lenders and other diligence teams (mainly tax, legal, strategy, post deal integration, purchase agreement, transition agreement).

Given my strong background, I bring to table skillsets that clients may find useful, which could possibly help me to succeed at Toptal. Let's see.

Monday, June 12, 2017

Key Metrics to Measure Functioning of a Healthcare System

Helped a friend some time ago to research key metrics that a government can use to monitor the efficiency of its health system. Thought will share it on my blog as well.

The health metrics used by governments around the world are highly contextual, geared at their specific targets. The presented metrics are based on internet search and can be further improved by conducting country specific research and employing health care professionals. As a disclaimer, I am not a health specialists and have relied heavily on the WHO framework. All sources used are duly mentioned below the post. I have tried to zero down on 10 key metrics as a way to focus on the basics and with a belief that doing everything often means doing nothing. I believe that starting with these would give an excellent start and help put in place a framework to support further improvement.

The aim is to help policy makers save time by presenting a one page memo for key items to focus on that help them create a widespread image of efficiency and transparency (people feel the system is functioning well), aiming for KPI management. While a ground up build up of health system is ideal, the framework would help to address visible change. More fundamental question of how to ensure long term improvement of the health system (e.g. having enough medical staff in the long run, promoting healthy lifestyle, planning investment into beds/ equipment etc.) is not directly addressed by these, though inevitably these would have to be considered to deliver these metrics in the long run. Happy for suggestions to improve this keeping in mind the objective.

Please note that some metrics are measures (need effort to quantify but can be quantified), others are boolean flags (it is done or not done). Use of technology would be critical for measuring success.
My key 10 metrics are:
1. Under 5 mortality rate per 1000
2. % of pregnant women with  at least 4 antenatal care visits during last pregnancy
3. % of 1 year olds fully immunised
4. % of women reported knowing about means of avoiding sexually transmitted diseases/ HIV/ birth control
5. Premature mortality rate (% of people dying before reaching the average life expectancy) with causes
6. Respect for the dignity of the patient (includes aspects of the interaction with providers such as courtesy and sensitivity) using surveys
7. Prompt attention to health needs: time lag between a person identifying the problem & coming to the hospital (distance travelled to get to the facility), being seen by the doctor & provided medicine (promptness of care/ availability of enough doctors & nurses), and cured (effectiveness of diagnosis: segment by disease)
8. Availability of basic amenities for patients: clean waiting rooms, adequate beds, and healthy/clean food when admitted
9. Cost of service delivery benchmarked against a standard cost (calculation methodology to be same), including efficiency of purchasing (cost and quality)
10. Provision for strategic leadership, preparation of financial statements and independent audits

Other metrics that you may want to consider once you have the above in place are:
1. Under 5 chronic malnutrition per 1000
2. Analysis of consumer protection cases to identify problem hospitals
3. State of communication of existing government hospitals with each other so that resources can possibly be pooled
4. Availability of physicians, nurses, community health workers etc. as perceived by patients
5. % of population denied care due to cost (if significant, explore options/cost for social insurance, increasing competition, etc.)
6. Controls in place to reduce shrinkage (theft, corruption) and use resources more efficiently
7. Resource analysis by key health facilities (how much money comes from government, fund-raising, donations, NGOs)


Key Sources:
1. WHO Urban HEART: Measuring Urban Health
2. WHO Framework for Health System Performance Assessment
3. Measurement Framework: Evaluating Efficiency Across Patient-Focused Episodes of Care (NATIONAL QUALITY FORUM, US)
4. European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies (LSE)


Thursday, May 25, 2017

Making Your Meditation Deeper

5 top tips from my experience to help beginners make their meditation deeper:

1. Choose a comfortable time and place
As you become more experienced, you will be able to be more flexible about this. However, when you are just starting it is better to choose a comfortable time and place where you know you will not be disturbed. Put your mobile on silent, wear something comfortable and sit comfortably with your spine straight (cross-legged or on a chair, as you prefer). Use a back support if you need one. The best times that work for me are either early morning or just before sleeping.

2. Have a relatively empty stomach before meditation, stay hydrated
Meditation works better with an empty stomach and a hydrated body. So, if you planning to meditate before sleeping plan to have an early, light/ easy to digest and easy on the stomach dinner. Avoid fried food, red meat, alcohol and very spicy food for dinner. If you experience a slightly heavy head post alternate nostril breathing, it is a sign of insufficient water intake.

3. Avoid caffeine, alcohol, nicotine and phone scrolling near meditation
The aim of meditation is to make your mind sharper and naturally alert. Therefore anything that either makes the mind jumpy, restless or dull needs to be avoided pre-meditation. Besides alcohol, coffee, tea and recreational drugs, this also includes endless Facebook and Whatsapp scrolling and TV binge!

4. Exercise
If you are a naturally very energetic person with a very active mind, settling down for meditation can be difficult. While breathing exercises can help with it, physical exercise would use up some of that nervous energy, allowing you to settle deeper.

5. Be regular
As with most things in life, practice makes perfect. So, don’t give up. There are some serious benefits to be reaped with regular meditation, and simply doing it regularly is the key to both unlocking these benefits and going deeper.

Thursday, December 15, 2016

Demonetisation in India

My take on the current demonetisation situation:

1. In current political climate it is suicidal to accept that you have made a mistake. BJP government will therefore not admit to any failings. Nevertheless, the implementation and benefits at this stage are unlikely to exceed the costs from current point of view.

2. Let this be a lesson for all leaders who think revolutionary changes are cool/ they can change a large entrenched, rotten system overnight with few, big moves. Ideas of Arthkranti (the guys who gave this idea to Modi), while appealing on paper, have no historical precedence of actually working. Changes need to be incremental, systematic and well thought of. Disruption is not always good and change is always slow & painful.

3. Modi has seriously underestimated the will of 97% people to evade taxes and stay out of the system by any means possible. It is not easy to seek people's direct cooperation to act against their self-interest, even if the move benefits the whole society.  

4. If Modi wants to salvage the situation, he can use the chaos and confusion created by this move to push through serious reforms to tackle root problems. Tax raids, pushing digital transactions, stronger anti-tax evasion rules and marginal tax on gold to enable tracking gold transactions are steps in the right direction. Bringing in the right to service act as envisioned by Dr JP + continual shift towards e-governance will stem more corruption than demonetisation. 

5. It is time to bring in laws to prevent disruption of Parliament

6. I still support Modi as I see him as a leader who intends to change the system for good. I have not seen any alternative leadership that I could trust more. I would happily support any national leader who offers a constructive, reasonable intelligent plan and a leadership and is capable of forming a stable government at the centre.

7. The only people who make mistakes are the ones who try to do something. Nevertheless history rewards only success, as highway to hell is often paved with good intentions. Modi may do well to remember this.

Thursday, December 31, 2015

Wishful thinking

The heart is not a friend, my own hands have become foes
The fate seems sealed with no end to woes
As I lie surrounded by darkness, bleeding barely breathing
Thinking about a life unlived, dreams unfulfilled, and promises broken
As life lingers, and pain extends
The mind races on roads that may never be
And I wonder about the million questions that I cannot think of anymore
I do want to fly and float, but here I am… sinking

Dreaming of warmth, o wishful thinking…

Tuesday, October 20, 2015

Narendra Modi's Masterplan for Indian Economy

While I don't actually know what NaMo is thinking, given his actions to date I think his plan for the economy is on the following lines: 

  1. Market India as an investor friendly country to get in FDI
  2. Promote "Digital India" to encourage a part of economy that does not need big infrastructure spend, and use it to promote e-governance
  3. Get manufacturing in India at least for domestic consumption (including defence) to create jobs and positive buzz. Defence export are less likely to be sensitive to transport costs (the penalty of poor infrastructure) and can boost Digital India
  4. Start building the infrastructure required to ultimately enable India to export manufactured goods 

For the first three to be sustainable, reining in bureaucracy to be more business friendly  and judicial reforms to reduce end-to-end judgement times would be needed. We are already seeing steps to make the bureaucracy toe the line. Whether it will work or not is to be seen.

There is no concrete step on judicial reforms, which is a concern. However, as long as NaMo is in power, a compliant bureaucracy in itself will make a world of difference. If Modi goes out of power, most of the gains are likely to be lost without judicial reforms.

These changes are hard, but step 4 will be the hardest. Indian export in manufacturing at global scale is simply not possible without a highly developed infrastructure, including state of the art container ports, express ways for large container trucks, and a functioning fast freight container rail routes. Privatisation of freight rail, strategic layout of roads, and integrated deep water ports are needed to match the logistics advantage for manufacturing in China. To give you a perspective, right now 7 of the world's busiest container ports are in China, who has strategically invested in its infrastructure to brilliantly support exports. Without doing the same Make in India (for export and not just internal consumption) will never be viable, and digital India+defence exports can take you only so far. 

Even if Modi delivers factually, he needs to up his game regarding communication and rein in a lying, agenda based main stream media. It is time that media houses were held accountable for what they publish as factual news. You can't run a lie to tarnish somebody's reputation as main news for 20 hours and then publish the apology as side news for 2 minutes.

Overall, these steps, if executed reasonably, can provide India a significant boost and actually turn it into a world power. However, it is a difficult battle against entrenched socialist practices/culture of non-performance, corruption, and protectionism. Add in a biased, lying, agenda based main stream media and desperate fight for survival by the existing corrupt order, and this gets even more interesting. Of course some of out neighbours would like to see us derail as well. NaMo alone can do only so much. I just hope it is enough...

Wednesday, June 17, 2015

Thinking about Game of Thrones Season 5

WARNING: if you have not seen Game of Thrones season 5, potential spoilers ahead

I love Game of Thrones for its realism and randomness, that very well mimics the harsh realities of the world and the games of power struggles. With each passing episode, the TV adaptation is finding it more and more difficult to depict Geroge R. R. Martin’s complex Song of Ice and Fire saga. Up until season 4 it was still alright, but season 5 has seen some big time misses that are a big-big let-down. Is budget an excuse? Seriously? Millions of people watch this series. Logically, with such a big established fan-base, funds should be the last concern. I guess it boils down to desire to make a certain amount of profit at all costs, probably due to a badly negotiated contract with HBO. Or maybe it was plain stupidity, hubris, or laziness by the producers. Whatever it was, the quality of season 5 has been the worse till date. As a fan, I am not happy. I would still watch season 6, but it would be so much better if George R. R. Martin comes out with his books instead…

My key gripe is losing the sense of realism and ignoring character build-up, which was not the case earlier. For example, when the sword fell on Ned’s neck, it was the end of story. Similarly the Red Wedding was unapologetically brutal. There were a few reality bloopers, but overall the story held. In the current season, however, I think that the following elements were done pretty badly:

Dorne:
Of course. The cartoonish sand snakes with absolutely no idea about intrigue was the worst possible addition to the show. The last scene when they poisoned Myrcella knowing that Trystane is going to be with Jaimie shows that they are so blinded by the desire for revenge that they are willing to put Trystane in harm’s way. Not very smart, are they? The overall character build up through the season was horrible, and Dorne was easily the worst part of the show.

Unsullied and the Fighting Pit:
Aren’t unsullied supposed to be elite fighters, known for their discipline and fighting in formidable formations? In this season they came across as normal soldiers, even sitting ducks. A little effort to show their class during their ambush in the alley and in the fighting pit would have helped. And while we are talking about fighting pits, what the hell were the Son’s of Harpy thinking? They threw so many spears at Drogon and none at the Mother of Dragons? They even let her key advisors escape once she flew away. Pretty lame and unrealistic.

Sansa:
Until the last moment Sansa had no clue where Littlefinger is taking her. Even then, she enters the situation without a concrete plan, trusting Baelish. And how does it turn out to be? Some people feel she is growing a spine and doing something. To me, it appears that she got short-changed by Littlefinger, and has no clue how to deal with the situation. Ultimately she has been forced to flee by jumping over the wall. Vale story line is lost for sure, and this compromise shows Sansa as a victim rather than a protégé. If that was the intention, then it has worked fine.

Stannis:
Stannis is known as one of the best military commanders in Westros. Therefore the last scene of him blindly walking into an ambush was unreal to say the least. And then, despite being at the front of the army, he ends up in a random jungle away from Ramsay and near Brienne. Seriously? It appears that the show runners were too tired and drained by this time to keep it real.

Other gaffes:
  • Tyrion bought by the slaver for a pittance. What happened to the fortune for a dwarf’s cock?
  • In the fight between the White Walker and Jon Snow, Snow is dealt many non-lethal attacks even though no such consideration is given to the Thenn. A blip in an otherwise well made battle


Wednesday, June 3, 2015

एक याद

वह पल थे जिन में हसरतें थीं,
मोहब्बत थी, जुनून था
वह पल थे जब इक नाम में दुनिया सिमट जाती थी,
जब मन्नतों में सिर्फ एक सूरत नज़र आती थी
वह पल थे जिन में हम ने इबादत सीखी,
चाहत सीखी, मोहब्बत सीखी
वह पल थे जब आँखों में नूर था,
दिल में मासूमियत थी, दीवानगी का सरूर था
उन पलों में बेचैन रह कर आँसू भी बहाये,
ज़र्रे-ज़र्रे में ढूँढा उसे, न किसी के करीब आये
वह पल कभी नहीं आएंगे वापिस,
वह पल कभी नहीं आएंगे
इस कसक को याद करेंगे हम भी कभी-कभी,
वह पल जब याद आएँगे

Thursday, February 19, 2015

Delhi Elections: Myths and Facts

Reading umpteen interpretations of the Delhi elections amuses me. It is funny and surprising how many prominent writers base their writing on 'opinions' rather than actual facts on the ground. Yes, everybody is entitled to have an opinion. However, if that opinion does not agree with reality, it cannot be published as a fact. Fiction and dreams can make good reads, but publishing them as news is irresponsible to say the least. Democracy critically depends on media to perform fact based, real reporting. Like that is going to happen...

Anyway, let us get to myth busting and fact checking. My favorite 5:

Myth 1: All the people rejected BJP and voted for AAP/ people abandoned BJP due to conduct of the right
Fact: BJP got more number of votes than last election. However, all Congress votes got consolidated behind AAP, thanks to their ground work and freebies. People who were supporting BJP did not abandon the party, if the numbers are correct. However, BJP did a poor job of convincing the swing voter. BJP's Delhi campaign was a disaster.

Myth 2: This is a historical election and India has never seen such results, so now AAP will go national for sure
Fact: Nope, sorry to burst your bubble. Many regional parties have attained similar level of results in the past in India. All of them are still regional parties.

Myth 3: AK's anti-corruption/swaraj/charisma led to AAP victories
Fact: A solid ground work by AAP volunteers, given enough time by a clueless BJP Delhi leadership, gave AK enough intelligence to formulate the right mix of promises. He played the game well, avoided confrontational politics, chose candidates carefully, got support from the Congress vote bank, gathered all enemies of NaMo, and spoke nonsense with confidence. It worked. AK played it well politically, and his tactics were excellent. It has, however, nothing to do with AAP's founding ideology.

Myth 4: AK cannot do anything without Modi's help
Fact: Modi's help would be needed for around 30% of his promises. Nevertheless, Delhi has a budget of INR 40,000 crore and clean govenance is always within reach.

Myth 5: It is ridiculous that AAP has a deputy CM and AK does not take any portfolio
Fact: This could prove immensely useful if AK is targeting Lok Sabha. He needs someone to fill the seat of CM once he takes the national stage, so training Sisodia is good strategy. Plus, not taking any portfolio would enable him to escape any blame and keep his reputation intact. It also gives him more time to build his image and unite NaMo's enemies over the next 5 years.

Friday, February 6, 2015

If Arvind Kejriwal Wins Delhi Elections

Much has been made out of Delhi elections by a desperate opposition, who perhaps see Arvind Kejriwal (AK) as their last hope of trying to put down Narendra Modi. Modi is a juggernaut that will not be stopped as easily, no matter if BJP wins or loses Delhi.

For AK, I personally turned against him when he refused to target Congress in the Lok Sabha and virtually fought on an anti-Modi platform. Plus his simplistic but effective rabble-rousing rhetoric, vote bank politics, and confrontational style of operation seriously put me off to the extent that I named him Kanjriwal. With every day he shifts a little more left to the centre, which I think should set the alarm bells ringing for most sensible people in India; especially given that India’s economy has suffered terribly due to years of left leaning politics. Yet I am amazed, surprised, and impressed by so many of my well-educated and well-meaning friends actively supporting AK. I don’t like AK much, but I do admire his ability to command such a high level of loyalty in such a short amount of time. I am not sure how much of that will stay, but it is good while it lasts.

My assessment is that the only reason AK wants to win Delhi elections is to use it as a grand stage to launch his next Lok Sabha (LS) campaign. Now, that is not necessarily a bad aim. However, given his track record so far, I have every reason to suspect that he would go about it in the worst possible way for the country.

If AK wins the upcoming elections, I predict that he will do everything he can to provoke NaMo. If this is about LS 5 years down the line, we will see an AK obsessed with NaMo. He would take every opportunity to be more than a little confrontational, which would seriously impact his ability to get anything done in Delhi. If anything goes wrong, he will blame NaMo, but will take all the credit for anything that goes right. I seriously expect to see a lot of posturing and very little work happening if he becomes the CM. His in-your-face, in-the-media, on dharna style of working will not work. We will just hear conspiracy theories and see lot of nonsense on TV. All the money would be wasted on populist freebies, with no investment for a permanent positive change. The funny thing is that it will be another major strategic blunder by AAP that may actually seal its fate, albeit at cost of 5 years to Delhi. So far AAP has shown that they are good with tactics. However, I am yet to see a comprehensive sensible strategic decision.

However, if AK decides to listen to people outside his comrades circle, he can take another trajectory as well. He can use the next 5 years to actually do something positive for Delhi, to actually demonstrate his ability to get things done. Sure, he can do his dramas and dharnas to get footage and mileage for LS and irritate the hell out of NaMo. At the same time he needs to work to deliver actual results on the ground. To get in businesses, create actual jobs, reduce corruption, and prevent hooliganism from his own cadre.

I will be extremely happy to be proved wrong. After all even Kejriwal’s assessment of not joining hands with Congress did prove to be wrong in the last polls. You never know, sometimes even a leopard can change his spots. 

Wednesday, January 21, 2015

Building a Party Constitution

One of the biggest challenge on the road to meritocracy will be building a sustainable organisation/ political party to support this change. Making a rough back of the envelope calculation, I would say the party would need 1 active volunteer for every 100 people in the population, and 1 leader/active participant for every 10 volunteers. Therefore, the core group would be ideally around 1% of the target population. That may appear small, but translates to around 10K active volunteers for a population of 1 million. Based on this, the approximate number of active volunteers & leaders needed to take the movement to a national level for some countries would be as follows:

China:  17.7M volunteers, 2M leaders
India: 12.7M volunteers, 1M leaders
USA:    3.2M volunteers, 300k leaders
Brazil: 2M volunteers, 200k leaders
Russia: 1.5M volunteers, 150k leaders
Japan: 1.3M volunteers, 130k leaders
Germany: 810k volunteers, 80k leaders
France: 660k volunteers, 66k leaders
UK:       640k volunteers, 64k leaders
South Africa: 540k volunteers, 54k leaders
Canada: 360k volunteers, 36k leaders
UAE:      100k volunteers, 10k leaders
Luxembourg: 6K volunteers, 600 leaders

United States Department of Defense, the largest employer in the world, employs 3.2 million people. 

The key point that I am trying to make is that the project would involve building an extremely large organisation, and will be harder for bigger countries. To be sustainable, at the minimum it would need a cohesive ideology that appeals to its members (both emotionally and logically), a suitable organisation structure, an effective fund-raising strategy, an effective succession mechanism, a party constitution, and an effective marketing strategy. 

With this view, I hereby begin the first draft for a sample consitution for a party whose sole motto is the progress of the nation based on the principles of meritocracy. The constitution is a work in progress and I will share it with you once it is in a respectable shape. Please feel free to pitch in your suggestions in the comments below, or just email me.

Tuesday, January 20, 2015

What's New About What I Say About Meritocracy?

Meritocracy, by any stretch of imagination, is not a new idea as you can learn from this Wikipedia page. Then, how is my contribution different, and why the hell am I spending so much time thinking and writing about it?

Most of the ideas about meritocracy that I have come across mainly focus on the "what" (the wise should rule). There are ways of getting smart people involved in governance structures and administrative services, dating back to ancient China. However, the role of meritocracy is often limited to getting the people but not extended to promoting them or rewarding the right behaviour in the long run. The focus on "how" to enshrine meritocracy as  way of life in a complex human society is missing, and often takes a very idealistic view of human nature. I also think that it does not pay enough attention to making the system "fool-proof" i.e. building in safety mechanisms to prevent degeneration. I hope my work will contribute in the direction of implementing a meritocracy on the ground.

The following writers, in no particular order, have inspired my thoughts: 

Ayn Rand (Atlas Shrugged, The Fountainhead)
Chanakya (Arthashastra)
Niccolo Machiavelli (Discourses on the first decade of Titus Livius, The Prince)
Plato (The Republic)
Robert Greene (48 Laws of Power)
Ronald A Heifetz (Leadership Without Easy Answers)
Sri Sri Ravi Shankar (God Loves Fun, etc.)

I have also relied on the political events that I have witnessed or read about during my own life time and my own experiences. Of course I have used the mighty Google to aid me with my little project :).

Thursday, January 8, 2015

मुर्शिद संग रह जाएगा

(Dedicated to H. H. Sri Sri Ravi Shankar)

बस मुर्शिद ही इक डोर है,
नहीं दूसरा कहीं कोई और है,
हर रंग और इक दिन उड़ जाएगा,
बस मुर्शिद संग रह जाएगा

हर रिश्ता सितारों का खेल है,
हर बंधन कुछ लम्हों का मेल है,
इक बस इश्क ही संग तेरे जाएगा
बस मुर्शिद संग रह जाएगा

खेल ज़िन्दगी का खेले 'सवीन',
ख़ुशी, गम सब पाए रंगीन,
इश्क-इश्क करता वो जाएगा,
बस मुर्शिद संग रह जाएगा...

Tuesday, December 23, 2014

Top 10 things to watch out on path to merit

A governance structure must guard against some pitfalls if it hopes to successfully implement its goals. Human nature is complex, and both simplistic and overly complex solutions can be exploited and subverted. However, with some safeguards it is possible to achieve and sustain progress. Any architect of meritocracy should keep the following in mind to ensure that meritocracy is sustainable:

1. Transparency is paramount for merit to flourish
For most public related issues, the information should be made available online and the processes need to be made transparent. Without transparency conspiracy theories take hold more easily, and people can come to believe that the meritocracy is not genuine. This can be onerous  and difficult without use of technology.

2. Equality of opportunity will sustain meritocracy
The system should be perceived as fair by people. Without equality of opportunity, meritocracy will degenerate into aristocracy, which will defeat the whole purpose of having a meritocracy.  

3. Too much inequality will destroy the social fabric
Inequality is inevitable. However, if 90% of the population is starving and underfed, then there is something seriously wrong with the governance structure. Meritocracy and a strong nation need wider participation of the population in the economy, which can be jeopardised by poverty. They can also become easy targets for communists and theological preachers, both of which can be a serious danger to the integrity of a country.

4. Too much power in too few hands will destroy the country 
Parallel institutions, sometimes even duplicate institutions can be critical to prevent abuse of power. Checks and balances, backed by a strong constitution can do wonders for a nation (even if it can be a bit chaotic).

5.  Right to accuse needs to be protected, but right to slander needs to be checked
It is important for citizens to be able to accuse and argue to forward their point of view. This would strengthen meritocracy and help weed out unwanted elements. However, slander and malicious propaganda can be used to damage reputation, cause needless fear and disgust in population, and weaken the social fabric. The law has to find a balance between encouraging criticism and preventing calumny. 

6. Rights should not come without responsibilities
In a meritocratic state, all rights (including human rights and voting rights) would need to come with a responsibility.

7. Avoid direct confrontation with religion, but side-line and weaken it
People should be free to follow their religious belief, but nation needs to take the front-seat. This would mean peaceful co-existence, complete stop on missionary activities, and a uniform civil code applicable to all. 

8. Nationalism with spirituality will hold meritocracy together
Every ideology needs a glue to hold it together. For meritocracy, nationalism can be an excellent binder. However, to prevent wars and rise of any kind of supremacists, it would need to incorporate certain degree of spirituality as well. I am open to idea, but in experience meditation and breathing techniques are a good, neutral starting point.

9. Do not expect status quo to roll-over and die
If only it was that simple. Do not underestimate the tenacity of vested interests and the dangers of a revolution. Without political power and a police/army firmly under civilian control, the changes will not be permanent. Managing media and a comprehensive communication strategy will be as critical as doing actual work.

10. Results Results Results
Theory and intention is all well, but if there are no concrete, actual results, the whole thing is meaningless and is probably being done wrong.

This is by no means an exhaustive list, but my top 10 nuggets of wisdom to the one who wants to walk the path. May the force be with you ;)

Friday, December 19, 2014

Starting on the Quest for Meritocracy


The implementation of a meritocratic state can begin with a leader supported by a group of individuals with the determination and the ability to implement a meritocratic state. The whole group would need an above average IQ, reasonable success in private life, nationalism, strong control on emotions, spirituality, ability to deal with own ego, and a reasonably good understanding of human nature. A little power hunger will not harm. It would help having experts (e.g. economics, technology, political science, marketing), leaders with practical work experience in their fields. 

While it is always ideal to have things from the "scratch", I am not an advocate of revolution as it is messy. Reform from within will be better for the society as a whole, but may be more difficult to implement due to entrenched vested interests of existing power centres. Nevertheless it is doable if done slowly but surely (boil the frog). Also, since human life is short, it is advisable to focus on the issues that are likely to have maximum impact and leave something for the next generation.

The ultimate aim would be political/legal/constitutional changes that institutionalise meritocracy. This is the only way to make meritocracy permanent. Economy and education are the primary tools to both work towards it and strengthen it.  However, before that can happen, to first gain traction the team needs to first work at the grass root level. 

This can begin with identify and solving key local problems, and then marketing the success. Consider the following two steps to identify problems to solve:

1. Zero down on a few key issues likely to lead to positive press for meritocracy (4 at most)
Meritocracy is not an established system. To start with, it needs to be in the press and recognised for its excellent results. In the beginning, it is advisable to focus on issues that are easy to market, popular, and doable. This is about picking battles big enough to matter and small enough to win, and important for at least 25% of the population. Surveys and reports, backed by information gained by working amidst people, should help in this. 

2. Analyse the identified issues and zero down on one to target
Consider team resources and expertise, ask for public opinion to identify pain points and possible improvements, analyse short-comings of current system, and prepare a plan of action.

In the beginning, it is advisable to not upset any existing power centres as far as possible. Ultimately they are going to get upset, but the later we upset them the lesser obstacles we would face in implementing our plans. 

In initial years, the aim should be to cultivate image of efficiency, integrity, and no-nonsense to demonstrate the capability of meritocracy. For this the team will have to both do the work and communicate it effectively to people. Get youth involved, use street plays, harness social media, conduct seminars/ talks, organise public/visible debates, create sponsorships for the best and the brightest. In short, get the word out there and back it up with actual, tangible results.

The ultimate aim is to enter the political sphere and change the way things are run. Therefore the core team would need to develop grass root level of cadres and work intensively amidst people: travelling, listening to their problems and aspirations, where possible helping them with their issues, vociferously highlighting identified public problems, and learning about the society. To begin with, for minimum resistance, the team should target an area that is:

  • reasonably prosperous and eager to boost its economic dominance; or 
  • sufficiently economically desperate and eager to turn-around its fortune. 

The areas with following characteristics could be very challenging and are best tackled at later stages:

  • strong religious or caste based influence
  • severely affected by militant/terrorist activity
  • strong influence of Communism

The group should also create a fund-raising plan and involve industrialists in their plans to ensure adequate financing.

These key steps should help the team to lay down the foundation for a meritocracy. 

Wednesday, December 10, 2014

Why We Need Meritocracy


It is useless to expect an oak tree to bear apples. Similarly, it is useless to expect governance systems designed to exploit and steal to deliver justice. Even though the world has evolved significantly, it is hard to find genuinely good leaders and 90% of the population is still languishing in poverty. I therefore think that the current governance systems have overall failed miserably to alleviate misery. The key reasons  are affliction with narrow interests, short-termism, mob mentality, and the concept of rights without responsibilities. The systems are well designed to pacify power groups and keep a few in charge of many. They are designed to enslave and not liberate, even if they claim otherwise.

Therefore it is very important for the thinkers and the doers to come together and work towards building a society that is governed by three basic principles:

  • always try to get one of the best people to do the job
  • rights come with responsibilities
  • it is not enough to theoretically endorse the above two principles: they have to be purposefully built into the very fabric of the nation

This, in essence, is meritocracy. And this, in essence, can be a extremely difficult to implement in practice. Even profit oriented corporations often find it difficult to stick to this simple mantra. For a nation it can be devilishly difficult.Nevertheless, it stands to reason that even partial implementation of these ideas should change the fortunes of a country for the better.

In future essays I will try to explore how I think a leader can implement it.

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

The Time for Merit

From the time human society has started organising itself, it's surroundings, intelligence, and knowledge level have had a profound effect on its governance structures. Through the ages we have seen various versions of rule of a man/ family (despotism, monarchy, aristocracy), rule of God (theocracy), rule of men (democracy, republic, socialism, communism, nationalism), rule of money (capitalism), and even no rule (anarchy). 

The first radical change  came via the advent of the printing press and the corresponding realtively wider availability of knowledge. This steadily eroded ideologies that rely on people's ignorance, and strengthened those that either empower or manipulate them. This ultimately led to the decline of theocracies and monarchies, and the rise of democracies, socialism, propoganda fuelled dictatorships, and capitalism. When combined with older forms of governance, this has produced a wide range of governance structures around the globe.

The knowledge that came with the printed word did not get rid the human race of thirst for power, control, and pseudo-superiority. In fact, it made the quest more sophisticated and destructive. As rulers adjusted to the shock of more informed and combatative subjects, they tweaked their tools of propaganda, terror and division. The same knowledge that developed  life saving drugs also came up with nuclear weapons. 
Promises of communist utopia often turned out to be despotic hells.

Nevertheless, democracy has slowly become the most common form of governance, and ideas of capitalism and socialism have both become deeply embedded in the system. However, the rise of the Internet, satellites and the ability of the rulers to track their "subjects" closely is changing things in a way that may see revival of totalitarian regimes, with even the current "free" democracies slowly eroding away the freedom of their citizens using propaganda, fear, monetary control, and intimidation.

Having said that, I think that these same technical advancements present an opportunity to build a strong, transparent, and meritocratic country. The happiness and prosperity of nations will be determined by their ability to command an effective economy, to generate superior scientific knowledge, and being militarily strong. This in turn would depend on having better people in top positions, which perhaps can be done more effectively in an inherent meritocratic system. I find the thought pretty appealing, and will write about it as and when I get time in form of similar articles. I hope somebody, somewhere, someday finds it useful and interesting.

Monday, November 3, 2014

एक प्रेम कहानी

दूध की बोतलों और राशन की कतारों में खोयी सी एक प्रेम कहानी
कुछ सिक्कों की खोज में गुम एक और प्रेम कहानी
थकी रातों की मसरूफ सुबहों का इंतज़ार करती प्रेम कहानी
सुनहरे कल को खोजती, परदेस में भटकती प्रेम कहानी
गुमसुम, उदास : पर जाने क्यों ना रोती प्रेम कहानी
फिर भी उम्मीद है कि ढूंढ लेगी अपनी मंज़िल अपनी प्रेम कहानी
क्योंकि है साथ जब तक मुर्शिद, रंगीन है यह अपनी प्रेम कहानी

Sunday, November 2, 2014

Being Happy

Happiness, I now truly know, is an attitude. This attitude is born in a free mind, and allows one to live more effectively. Freedom, in turn, is a direct function of one’s ability to think, their commitment to spirituality (which is not the same as religion), and the intensity of desire to be self-aware.

What do I mean by the ability to think? Beyond clichés there is thought: the genuine, actual ability of human mind to create an idea and express a first-hand opinion. This is, however, hard work for both hard pressed and ignorant alike. One group is caught in the perpetual struggle to survive and make it through each day, wondering if there is an end to this winding road. The other is simply unaware, sleep walking through life. And both are, in ways, enslaved by their fears and prejudices. Bounded by what they know and what they don’t know, stuck in the middle of nowhere.

What does thinking do? It simply opens doors and aids the process of self-awareness. It is one of the key initial tools towards the path of self-realisation. Humans rule this planet due to their ability to think, and they can become self-aware because they can think. Thinking is, however, a two edged sword that needs the guiding hand of spirituality. Spirituality leads thought to freedom and not self-destruction.

But what is spirituality? For me, being a good human being is the essence of spirituality. Practices that reduce stress without harming your health, hence allowing you to be a better and more effective human, are spiritual practices. Vedic breathing techniques (pranayama, Sudarshan Kriya) and yoga are potent spiritual practices that I have experienced first-hand. There may be other techniques, but I am not aware about them.

Finally, one needs self-awareness to be truly happy. Without self-awareness even spirituality can give a false sense of accomplishment, ego, superiority complex, and illusion of control.

What is self-awareness? For me, self-awareness consists of understanding one’s conscious self, learning from mistakes, learning the art of handling the mind, and taking conscious decisions. Art of Living teaches various techniques to aid this process, though I am sure there will be other schools teaching similar things. To start on the path of self-awareness, however, one needs some initial amount of thinking and the realisation that self-awareness is of paramount importance.


At some point of my life I believed that we also need sufficient money and good relationships to be truly free. From my experience, I have learned that pursuit of money can as easily bring in more unhappiness to the one who does not make an effort to become self-aware. It is the same story with relationships. As Sri Sri says, to meet your soul mate you first need to first meet your soul. All in all, without the self-awareness that emanates from spirituality and first-hand thinking, everything in this world will ultimately lead to sorrow.