Tuesday, January 10, 2012

For the crime of success

Recently, I have been reading a lot about the rising inequality in the US, its possible effects on the upcoming presidential elections, and even fears about the same happening in the UK.

I have two points to make.

Firstly, economic equality, as much as anybody may want it, is an ephemeral chimera that at best can cause frustration in the society and at worst lead to birth of a mediocre, self-annihilating socialist state. Even communists, with all the bloodshed and programs, were unable to achieve it. Are we really thinking of achieving it in an apparently capitalistic society? Nevertheless, we can (and should) aim for absolute equality before law and possible equality of opportunity for everybody, without fear or prejudice. That means making corporate lobbying and graft difficult. It also means making employment laws more meritocratic and employment process more transparent. It does not mean demonising the successful and ramming down their throat socialist taxes for the crime of being successful.

Secondly, it will be a mistake to make the current state of US economy a matter of class-warfare or a matter of punishing corporate America in the upcoming election. In the end, it is corporate America that will create jobs. Instead, the public of Unites States needs to do extensive soul-searching to understand what is blighting a great country. Is it really just greedy corporate? Easy answers are seldom right. If the country of democracy and free-enterprise is held hostage to things like corporate lobbying, excessive litigation, disintegrating social fabric, and a new-found worry about equality, something has gone wrong horribly somewhere down the line. Discouraging industry will only make it worse.

As unions and score of people cry out for good jobs and better pays, I am almost tempted to ask them to pluck it from the bush they think it grows on. Successful people make the jobs possible, demonising them is the worst possible thing that the society can possibly do to itself.