Wednesday, June 17, 2015

Thinking about Game of Thrones Season 5

WARNING: if you have not seen Game of Thrones season 5, potential spoilers ahead

I love Game of Thrones for its realism and randomness, that very well mimics the harsh realities of the world and the games of power struggles. With each passing episode, the TV adaptation is finding it more and more difficult to depict Geroge R. R. Martin’s complex Song of Ice and Fire saga. Up until season 4 it was still alright, but season 5 has seen some big time misses that are a big-big let-down. Is budget an excuse? Seriously? Millions of people watch this series. Logically, with such a big established fan-base, funds should be the last concern. I guess it boils down to desire to make a certain amount of profit at all costs, probably due to a badly negotiated contract with HBO. Or maybe it was plain stupidity, hubris, or laziness by the producers. Whatever it was, the quality of season 5 has been the worse till date. As a fan, I am not happy. I would still watch season 6, but it would be so much better if George R. R. Martin comes out with his books instead…

My key gripe is losing the sense of realism and ignoring character build-up, which was not the case earlier. For example, when the sword fell on Ned’s neck, it was the end of story. Similarly the Red Wedding was unapologetically brutal. There were a few reality bloopers, but overall the story held. In the current season, however, I think that the following elements were done pretty badly:

Dorne:
Of course. The cartoonish sand snakes with absolutely no idea about intrigue was the worst possible addition to the show. The last scene when they poisoned Myrcella knowing that Trystane is going to be with Jaimie shows that they are so blinded by the desire for revenge that they are willing to put Trystane in harm’s way. Not very smart, are they? The overall character build up through the season was horrible, and Dorne was easily the worst part of the show.

Unsullied and the Fighting Pit:
Aren’t unsullied supposed to be elite fighters, known for their discipline and fighting in formidable formations? In this season they came across as normal soldiers, even sitting ducks. A little effort to show their class during their ambush in the alley and in the fighting pit would have helped. And while we are talking about fighting pits, what the hell were the Son’s of Harpy thinking? They threw so many spears at Drogon and none at the Mother of Dragons? They even let her key advisors escape once she flew away. Pretty lame and unrealistic.

Sansa:
Until the last moment Sansa had no clue where Littlefinger is taking her. Even then, she enters the situation without a concrete plan, trusting Baelish. And how does it turn out to be? Some people feel she is growing a spine and doing something. To me, it appears that she got short-changed by Littlefinger, and has no clue how to deal with the situation. Ultimately she has been forced to flee by jumping over the wall. Vale story line is lost for sure, and this compromise shows Sansa as a victim rather than a protégé. If that was the intention, then it has worked fine.

Stannis:
Stannis is known as one of the best military commanders in Westros. Therefore the last scene of him blindly walking into an ambush was unreal to say the least. And then, despite being at the front of the army, he ends up in a random jungle away from Ramsay and near Brienne. Seriously? It appears that the show runners were too tired and drained by this time to keep it real.

Other gaffes:
  • Tyrion bought by the slaver for a pittance. What happened to the fortune for a dwarf’s cock?
  • In the fight between the White Walker and Jon Snow, Snow is dealt many non-lethal attacks even though no such consideration is given to the Thenn. A blip in an otherwise well made battle


No comments: